Conflicting LDS Scriptures

    which demonstrate their beliefs and teachings are not only different from those of Christianity,
    but they conflict with their own (usually earlier) writings

     

    Some Inconsistences tabulated...
    Specific Topic
    Mormon Scripture Says...
    Contrasting Mormon Scripture Says...
    King James Version says...
    God...
    is He an
    Exalted
    Man
    ?
    NO
    Believest thou that
    this Great Spirit,
    who is God, created all things?
    BOM Alma 18:28
    YES
    The Father has a body of flesh
    and bones as tangible as man's;
    the Son also
    D & C 130:22
    NO
    God is a Spirit...
    John 4:24
    God is not a man...
    Num 23:19
    Father, Son,
    and the
    Holy Ghost
    are the
    ONE GOD
    YES
    Which Father, Son and
    Holy Ghost are one God,
    infinite and eternal
    D & C 20:28
    NO
    Father, Son and Holy Ghost
    comprise the Godhead.
    As each of these persons
    is a God...
    a plurality of Gods exists
    Mormon Doctrine pps 576, 577
    YES
    For there are three that bear
    record in heaven, the
    Father, the Word, and the
    Holy Ghost;
    and these three are one
    1John 5:7
    Is God
    eternal?
    YES
    For I know that God is not a
    partial God, neither a changeable
    being; but He is unchangeable
    from all eternity to all eternity
    BOM Moroni 8:18
    NO
    We have imagined and supposed that
    God was God from all eternity.
    I will refute that idea
    Mormon Doctrine p321
    YES
    The eternal God is thy refuge
    Deut 33:7
    Does God
    Change?
    NO
    There is a God in heaven, who
    is infinite and eternal, from
    everlasting to everlasting,
    the same unchangeable God
    D & C 20:17
    YES
    We believe in a God who is Himself
    progressive... whose perfection
    consists in eternal advancement
    Articles of Faith p430
    NO
    For I am the LORD,
    I change not
    Malachi 3:6
    Is there a
    Plurality
    of Gods?
    NO
    The Father and the Son and
    the Holy Ghost are one...
    and whoso shall declare more
    or less than this, and
    establish it for my doctrine,
    the same cometh of evil
    BOM 3Nephi 11:27, 40
    YES
    These three are the only Gods we
    worship. But in addition there is
    an infinite number of holy personages,
    drawn from worlds without number,
    who ... are gods
    Mormon Doctrine p576, 577
    NO
    I AM He.
    Before Me there was
    no God formed,
    neither shall there be
    after Me
    Isaiah 43:10
    Can men
    be Gods?
    NO
    Now Zeezrom said:
    Is there more than one God?
    And he answered, No
    BOM Alma 11:28, 29
    YES
    Then shall they
    (those resurrected)
    be gods, because
    they have no end
    D & C 132:20
    NO
    Thus saith the LORD...
    besides me
    there is no God
    Isaiah 44:6
    Did God
    create man?
    YES
    And I, God,
    created man
    in mine own image
    PGP Moses 2:27
    NO
    Man was also in
    the beginning with God ...
    For man is spirit
    D & C 93:29, 33
    YES
    And the LORD God
    formed man
    Genesis 2:7
    Can God be
    seen?
    NO
    For without this
    (the authority of the priesthood)
    no man can see the face of God,
    even the Father, and live
    D & C 84:22
    (Joseph Smith did not have
    the priesthood when he
    claimed to see God)
    YES
    And he (Moses) saw God
    face to face, and
    he talked with him...
    Moses could endure
    His presence
    PGP Moses 1:2
    NO
    No man hath seen
    God at any time...
    the only-begotten Son...
    hath declared him
    John 1:18
    Is Jesus the
    One True God?
    YES
    Blessed be the name of
    the Most High God.
    And they did fall down at
    the feet of Jesus
    and did worship him.
    BOM 3Nephi 11:17
    NO
    Jesus Christ a seperate and
    distinct personage...
    three distinct personages
    and three gods
    Teachings of the
    Prophet Joseph Smith p370
    YES
    Now unto the King Eternal,
    immortal, invisible,
    the ONLY wise God
    (Speaking of Jesus Christ)
    1Timothy 1:17
    Is Jesus Christ
    Eternal?
    YES
    ... from all eternity
    to all eternity,
    the Great I AM,
    even Jesus Christ
    D & C 39:1
    NO
    Christ, the Firstborn,
    was the mightiest of all the
    spirit children of the Father
    Mormon Doctrine, p590
    YES
    whose goings forth
    have been...
    from everlasting
    Micah 5:2
    Was Jesus
    born of
    a Virgin?
    YES
    And behold, he shall be born
    of Mary at Jerusalem (!!)...
    she being a virgin
    BOM Alma 7:10
    NO
    Christ was begotten by
    an immortal father in
    the same way that mortal men
    are begotten by mortal fathers
    Mormon Doctrine p547
    YES
    When as his mother Mary
    was espoused to Joseph,
    before they came together,
    she was found with child
    Matthew 1:18
    Is the Way
    to salvation
    solely
    through Jesus?
    YES
    Behold, Jesus Christ is the
    name... there is none other
    name given whereby men
    can be saved
    D & C 18:23
    NO
    The President of the Church of
    Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
    holds the keys of salvation
    for all men now living...
    Mormon Doctrine p411
    YES
    one mediator between God
    and men, the man,
    Jesus Christ
    1Timothy 2:5
    Does
    Christ's blood
    cleanse us from
    all sin?
    YES
    ... Salvation was, and is, and
    is to come, in and through
    the atoning blood of Christ,
    the Lord Omnipotent
    BOM Mosiah 3:18
    NO
    ... for the blood of Christ alone
    under certain circumstances
    will not avail
    (for atonement of sins)
    Mormon Doctrine page 93
    YES
    ... and the blood of Jesus
    Christ his Son cleanseth
    us from ALL sin
    1John 1:7
    Is salvation
    by grace alone,
    not by works?
    YES
    And we know that
    justification through the grace
    of our Lord and Saviour,
    is just and true
    D & C 20:30
    NO
    That by keeping the
    commandments they might
    be washed and cleansed
    from all their sins...
    D & C 76:52
    YES
    For by grace are ye saved
    through faith,
    and not of yourselves;
    it is the gift of God;
    not of works
    Ephesians 2:8,9
    Is there
    salvation
    after death?
    NO
    For behold, if ye have
    procrastinated the day of your
    repentance even until death...
    the devil hath all power over
    you; and this is the final state
    of the wicked
    BOM Alma 34:35
    YES
    ... in relation to the dead...
    for their salvation is necessary
    and essential to our salvation...
    that they without us
    cannot be made perfect
    D & C 128:15
    NO
    And as it is appointed
    unto men once to die,
    but after this
    the judgement
    Hebrews 9:27
    Is hell
    everlasting
    destruction
    ?
    YES
    yea, they were encircled about
    by the bands of death,
    and the chains of hell,
    and an everlasting
    destruction did await them
    BOM Alma 5:7
    NO
    Whomsoever, therefore receives
    God's punishment, receives
    eternal punishment, whether it is
    endured one hour, one day,
    one week, one year, or an age
    Plan of Salvation pamphlet
    distributed by elders
    YES
    And the smoke of their
    torment ascendeth up for
    ever and ever; and they
    have no rest day or night
    Revelation 14:11

     

      Quotations from the book of Mormon are prefixed BOM, from the Pearl of Great Price PGP, and from the Doctrine and Commandments are prefixed D & C.

      References from the Holy Bible are identified with either the name of the book in full, or recognised abbreviations. The text used is that of the 1611 translation, known (incorrectly) to many people as the King James Version.

      The correct name of the translation is the Authorised Version, and in fact 80 percent of its content is lifted directly from the 1535 Coverdale Translation.

      In actual fact, the Authorised Version never set out to be a translation... this can be read from the epistle dedicatory at the front of it. It states that exisiting translations were "diligently compared".

      We have used it here, because it is the only version of the bible acceptable to Latter-Day Saints, who at one time taught quite erroneously that all other versions are paraphrases of the AV.

      While it should be noted that the Latter-Day Saint church insists that its only doctrines are found in the Authorised Version of the Bible, the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price, the other works quoted above are all used for the instruction of their members in Priesthood and Relief Society meetings, in Sunday Schools, in Seminary and Institute of Religion classes.

      This writer believes it is a hollow and spurious claim that those works cannot be regarded as doctrine.

      Bruce R McConkie who wrote Mormon Doctrine in the 1960s was a relatively recent member of the Quorum of Twelve Apostles of the church, and was on the paid headquarters staff when he wrote the book. He also headed up the Southern Australian Mission (based at Melbourne) in the early and mid 1960s.

      Dr. James E Talmage who wrote Jesus the Christ and the expanded teaching on the Articles of Faith was also an Apostle, earlier in the 20th century.

      Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith was compiled by Joseph F Smith, a descendant of his, who was subsequently the LDS church's prophet and president.

      It is this author's belief that these men knew what they were writing.


    More information
    Buyer Beware - The House of the Lord - KJV only - Conflicting LDS scriptures - Rewrites of the D & C
    - not the same - A vision for an ex-Mormon congregation

    Site Navigation
    Home Page - Define "Mormon" - LDS Scriptures - Other Books - Changes - Chat Channel - Links - contact us

    last updated 19th December 2001